*NO PROMO CODE NEEDED! BUY 2 BOXES SAVE $5!! (Baker’s Choice box NOT included) CHECK OUT OUR BAKER’S CHOICE BOX, NEW FLAVORS WEEKLY ONLY $20! ALL SHIPMENTS GO OUT MONDAYS OR TUESDAYS

**Baker's Choice - See Facebook and Instagram for current flavors

  • Sale
  • $20


Something new! We will have a mixed box with 3-4 flavors, some new and some favorites! Each week the box changes so follow @butterandlovegourmetcookies on Facebook and Instagram for the flavors. The box will be only available for the weeks listed below. 

Week 5 HALLOWEEN Baker’s Choice Box: Available 10/17-10/24. Local deliveries made 10/26, shipments go out 10/27. This weeks’ box includes a Spooky Chocolate Chip (chocolate chip with sprinkles), Cookies N’ Cream, German Chocolate Cake, and available only in this box Pumpkin Crunch! (Pumpkin Rice Krispy Treat center, dipped in Chocolate) 

*NO LONGER AVAILABLE* Week 4 FALL Baker’s Choice Box: Available 10/9- 10/16. Local deliveries made 10/18, shipments go out 10/19. This weeks’ box includes Chocolate Peanut Butter, Chocolate Salted Caramel, Pumpkin Spice Snickerdoodle, and only available in this box, Candied Pecan Chocolate Chip! 

*NO LONGER AVAILABLE* Week 3 FALL Baker’s Choice Box: Available 10/3-10/9. Local deliveries made 10/11,  shipments go out 10/12.  This weeks’ box includes Chocolate Peanut Butter, Cookies an’ Cream, Apple Crumble and only available in this box, Pumpkin Spice S’mores! 


*NO LONGER AVAILABLE- Week 2 FALL Baker’s Choice Box: Available 9/26- 10/2 Ship date 10/5, delivery date 10/4. This weeks box will have our most popular cookie Snickerdoodle, Chocolate-Chocolate Chip Cookie dough, Cookies n’ Cream, and only available in this box Salted Caramel Apple Pie! 

*NO LONGER AVAILABLE - Week 1 Available 9/4-9/25 Ship dates 9/8, 9/14, 9/15, 9/28, 9/29. Delivery dates 9/6, 9/13, 9/27. We are kicking off the fall with an exciting new flavor! This box will have our newly returned Chocolate Snickerdoodle, Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Salted Caramel, and only available in this box... Pumpkin Spice Snickerdoodle CHEESECAKE!!